Coke and Huiyuan: The Real Rules for Foreigners Buying Chinese Companies

So the Finanace Ministry rejected Coca Cola’s $2.5 billion bid for China’s biggest juice maker, Huiyuan. The pruchase would have broken the new anti-monopoly law, apparently. There’s plenty of good balanced analysis out there from the likes of Bloomberg and others about why this happened. But over at the China Law Blog, we get a refreshingly blunt  (and rather smugly self-congratulatory but I guess they have reason to be so) cut-to-the-chase look at the real (if unspoken) rules for foreign investors trying to buy mainland companies: 

Foreigners are permitted to purchase small Chinese companies that the central government is not interested in managing.Foreigners are permitted to purchase large, state-owned enterprises that suffer from financial difficulty, provided the foreign investor agrees to restructure the purchased company.

Foreigners are permitted to purchase non-majority interests in strong, successful Chinese companies, but only if there is some added benefit, such as transfer of technology, advanced management or access to foreign markets.

Foreigners are not permitted to purchase a majority interest in a large and financially successful Chinese company. Even smaller companies are off the table if they are financially sound and work in a core technology field or have created a strong or historically important brand.

Related Topics: China
  • Latest on Global Spin

    Pablo Martinez Monsivais / AP

    Obama’s Afghanistan Problem: Neither Karzai Nor the Taliban Like the ‘Reconciliation’ Script

    President Barack Obama huddled with President Hamid Karzai in Chicago on Sunday, urging Afghanistan’s leader to accelerate negotiations with the Taliban over a political solution to the longest war in America’s history. But the prospect for Karzai negotiating successfully with the insurgents is clouded by a question raised by Josef Stalin, on the eve of World War II, in response to the suggestion that he offer concessions to the Pope: “How many divisions does he have?” The Taliban now ask the same question about Karzai. And should the Afghan leader also ask himself the question, he might reach a similarly dispiriting conclusion. Karzai’s independent power base is minimal, as is his ability to influence the outcome of his country’s civil war absent direct U.S. involvement. And that gives neither Karzai nor the Taliban much incentive to cut a deal with the other.

    JOSEPH EID/AFP/GettyImages

    Must-Reads from Around the World, May 21, 2012

    Spillover - Lebanon’s Daily Star reports on escalating violence inside the country after soldiers shot dead a prominent anti-Bashar al-Assad Muslim preacher Sunday. “The gravity of the incident… prompted leaders on both sides of the political divide to call for calm and restraint to prevent the country from sliding into sectarian strife as a result of a spillover of the 15-month-old uprising in neighboring Syria,” it says.

    UPPA / ZUMAPRESS

    A Royal Party: Britain Celebrates 60 Years of Queen Elizabeth II

    From parades to concerts, and even tea with commoners, 86 year-old Queen Elizabeth II is traversing the United Kingdom to commemorate her Diamond Jubilee.

  • johnsmith9876

    Sounds like the US should impose all these rules about Chinese and Chinese government acquisition of US companies too.

  • bbcredux

    to johnsmith, the US have already set the tone by denying Chinese companies in the past from buying American companies, such as the Unocal purchase, and putting road blocks when Chinese appliance companies wanted to buy Maytag, for example. Not only that, Lenovo’s purchase of IBM’s computer division almost fell through because of US political interference. Given the hostility of the US when it came to Chinese companies buying US companies, the Huiyan case is long overdue. China is just playing tit for tat for something the US started.

  • http://chinaopps.com/blog/?p=17353 Coke’s Failed China Deal. Private Equity Will Live To Do Deals Another Day. |

    [...] Enough with the death knell pronouncements. Foreign private equity investments in China is not going to die, but it will need to modify. Wise foreign private equity firms are going to need to focus on the types of deals that have a real potential to work in China. China will accept the following sorts of foreign deals: [...]

  • conscienceinchina

    After the bristletails eat up all the properties of the “state-run” campany , they are “permitted to purchase”. Provided that these companies still remain a small piece of flesh to be carved up, the CCP will never give up their grip. A majority of the “state-owned enterprises” have been devoured to fall down.

  • justrecently

    Geez. Please build a WEBSITE, conscienceinchina! This is JUST A COMMENTER THREAD!!!

  • loveuchina

    conscienceinchina,you are so ridiculous!SHAME ON YOU!

  • laohong

    @conscienceinchina
    Your brother-in-arm Gao Zhisheng is still far from qualified as survivor. He could make him a perfect hero only after being water-boarded in Guantanamo.

    @Johnsmith,
    –”US should impose all these rules about Chinese and Chinese government acquisition of US companies”?
    You are not well informed that USA has had all the rules already. And it was USA that threw the first punch and even a second punch.

  • conscienceinchina

    The “five-jiaos” came in time! but now I have to leave for my bed, wait for my storm please, Commies!

  • conscienceinchina

    to the “justrecently”:

    If you were such a “justicial” person, you should blame the tyranny and the butchers hurriedly, instead of me!

  • conscienceinchina

    To the “loveuchina”:

    You should be named “love u CCP”, exactly.

    It’s nothing, that I just “shame” you and your master CCP. But you shame the whole Chinese and human beings!!!

  • conscienceinchina

    To the “laohong”:

    You are right. I am worrying about my “brother” Gao, the bravest one among the warriors fighting the dictator, with the world. And the all on which Gao has been tortured and excruciated must backfire on you and your master when the CCP fall down!!

  • conscienceinchina
  • justrecently

    conscienceinchina: The tyranny and the butchers are responsible for a lot of things. But when you flood comment threads with complete articles, that is your decision. A link to an article should be enough. As far as I can tell, commenting is for ones thoughts on an article, not for an article itself.
    That said, it is of course up to you how you want to communicate with other commenters and authors.

  • laohong

    @conscienceinchina

    –”when the CCP fall down!!”?
    In your still long life time you will obviously see that day, as spoonfed by CNN and your high school teacher yesterday.

  • zyamd

    外国人可以购买那些中国政府没有兴趣管理的小公司.如果愿意投资重组,外国人可以购买遭受财政危机的中国大型国有企业.
    只要他们可以带来好处,比如提供技术,先进的管理,或有利于出口,外国人可以购买微利的大型中国企业.
    外国人不能购买获利丰厚的大型中国企业.甚至对于小公司,只要它在财政上取得成功且位于核心技术领域,著名的或曾经著名的,都不能被外国人收购.

  • conscienceinchina

    To the “laohong”:

    You are always right, good boy! I really want to have a “long life time” so as to witness how you and your master will be garroted. So, wish you a “long life time” too.

  • conscienceinchina

    To “justrecently”:

    It’s not too bad that so far you admonished me just on my “commenting method”, not on the miserable and brutal stories I posted as well as my views.

    Considering I never get in the way of your rights to comment here, I suggest that whether the form of my comments is appropriate must be decided by the moderators here on “the China Blog”.

  • justrecently

    Considering I never get in the way of your rights to comment here, I suggest that whether the form of my comments is appropriate must be decided by the moderators here on “the China Blog”.
    Indeed. I admire their patience. This thread here, btw, is about Coca Cola and Huiyuan. And my comment on Friday wasn’t an admonishment, but a spontaneous request in capital letters.
    Take it easy.

  • laohong

    conscienceinchina son,
    High time for you low IQ to have your own counter-rally in DC to garantee your beloved mate Gao Zhisheng a last chance of water boarding to become a perfect hero.
    http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5gbpZpzf22HQklONb49NWXybzhSAgD972MMNO0

  • 2morrow2

    Simon,
    The “China Law Blog” link leads us to nowhere … please check…

  • 2morrow2

    I visited the World of Coca Cola in Atlanta last year and was amazed by the ambition and achievement of this global empire.

  • conscienceinchina

    To “justrecently”:

    I admire their patience too, indeed. They (CNN moderators) can even endure an enormous amount of nonsenses and lies created by the “five-jiaos(Wumaos)”, what else they can not suffer?

    But quaere, who prescribes here that the comment must accurately follow the text? Indeed, your own comments correcting me are not matching the theme too. And if you have time off, you may refer to the all dated comments here to make sure whether each of them is according your “request”.

    —justrecently Says:

    Indeed. I admire their patience. This thread here, btw, is about Coca Cola and Huiyuan. And my comment on Friday wasn’t an admonishment, but a spontaneous request in capital letters.
    Take it easy.

  • conscienceinchina

    To the Wumao “laohong”:

    So far you are the most brazen and shameless five-jiao here who scorn to conceal his real identity. You did a good job breaking one rule of the five-jiao’s work manual “covering up your real status”. Your abnormality has harmed the repute of all five-jiaos who are usually “patriots”.

    It’s inspiring that the warriors are still insisting on their ideal despite the excruciations, torture and massacres. Democracy will never be stopped by the tyranny and you animals.

    —laohong Says:
    @conscienceinchina
    Your brother-in-arm Gao Zhisheng is still far from qualified as survivor. He could make him a perfect hero only after being water-boarded in Guantanamo.

    —laohong Says:
    conscienceinchina son,
    High time for you low IQ to have your own counter-rally in DC to garantee your beloved mate Gao Zhisheng a last chance of water boarding to become a perfect hero.

    —Note: Gao zhisheng(高智晟), Chinese most famous and honorable human rights lawyer, who has been and is being brutally detained, tortured, excruciated, sentenced by the CCP regime for a long time. His current whereabout is unknown.

    “Waterboarding”, a form of torture. It consists of immobilizing the victim on his or her back with the head inclined downwards, and then pouring water over the face and into the breathing passages. By forced suffocation and inhalation of water the subject experiences drowning and is caused to believe they are about to die.(From Wikipedia)

  • tanboontee

    Well. I do not see anything unbecoming in what China is doing. It is precisely the salient form of protectionism that the new paradigm of the West is now promoting.

    By the way, did the US not reject earlier the Chinese attempt to buy over one of its iconic firms?

    So, why all the hoo-hah?
    (Tan Boon Tee)

  • justrecently

    Well – my recommendations come free of charge, conscience. But life’s to short to have long discussions with people like you who are actually mere clones of the CCP – quote:
    conscienceinchina Says:
    Saturday, March 21, 2009 at 1:24 pm
    To the “laohong”:
    You are always right, good boy! I really want to have a “long life time” so as to witness how you and your master will be garroted. So, wish you a “long life time” too.
    unquote.
    For the sake of not messing the thread up further, I’m leaving it here. I guess you are getting too much attention anyway.

  • conscienceinchina

    Well, “justrecently”, seems you are pinning something, as well as ignoring something. By quoting my fighting back, you are actually acquiescing some inhuman sneer and schadenfreude towards Gao who are being cruelly excruciated, and attack on me. Your bias is obviously!

  • laohong

    To conscienceinchina son,
    –”warriors are still insisting on their ideal…Democracy will never be stopped by the tyranny”?

    You know what? When I was fighting for democracy some 30 years ago in China, your mother was still a virgin in the country village waiting to be lifted up from poverty-line by CCP. I just wonder how ridicular “democracy’ sounds from an low IQ and psycomplex like you, when the word become a cheap luxury. You are too dense to know what you called “warriors or dissidents” are only a small bunch of human gabbages consist of only 0.001% of Chinese population and what you consider as “ideal” is nothing new to millions of Chinese intellectuals. The difference is they prefer to sacrifice the ideal for the moment for a stronger China while your type including Gao Zhisheng are willing to sell your lubed azz to US neo-cons who never stop dreaming to keep CHina weak in their geopolitical agenda.
    As to your calling me and everybody here as a “50-cent”, I repeat it again–In a dog’s eyes, all human being you are barking at look the same.

  • sing666

    conscienceinchina is Falon Gong. The rest is for your own judgement.

  • laohong

    Forget “conscienceinchina” idiot who knows nothing about China and back to the main topic about Coke and Huiyuan:

    I think obviously Mr. Simon Elegant and many here missed the key issue:
    Both Coke and Huiyuan are foreign companies in China. Coke is registered in America while Huiyuan in the Cayman Island.
    So why the fuss on China, like always?
    I guess my tip can save Mr. Elegant a hasty report which would be loved only by “conscienceinchina” type but laughed at by smart people.

  • sing666

    I watched the demonstration of Falon Gong followers in Toronto couple of years ago with amazement. They claimed that CCP was collapsing because over 10 millions of their members had turned in their membership cards and the rest would burn in hell. First, they were a group advocating breathing exercise. Then Li proclaimed their breathing exercise could cure all kinds of disease and protect their practitioners from fire and etc. Now, they are working towards total destruction of CCP. Their dreams are even bigger than that of Justrecently and Chinatoon. Talking about idiots of all kinds. It is a great entertainment here. LOL

  • conscienceinchina

    哈哈哈哈!连“加拿大五毛”都来了,真热闹啊!这些走狗们仗着它们主子的淫威,明目张胆,肆无忌惮地在这里胡作非为,居然张狂到不屑于掩饰自己的奴才鹰犬身份,看来它们是作垂死挣扎了。如果不幸中国的民主革命又一次以暴力为载体来实现,这些人人恨之入骨,恨不得剥其皮吃其肉的下流下贱的五毛党成员们,下场如何,可想而知,恐怕不会比高智晟所遭受的折磨要好到哪里去。

  • conscienceinchina

    The “laohong”, “sing666″, and all the members of “five-jiao-party” here:

    Now I don’t need to disclose your flunky role any more, as you have done it.

    I really want to explore the world of your deep hearts, the comrades. By doing such speech-not-from-conscience works every day, you must have run into a mental and psychological disturbing. In addition, seeing and hearing your superiors who have all become millionaires by corruption, contrasting your own hand-to-mouth income made up by five jiao, and the lowest and cheapest status among all the CCP flunkies, you should get mad and desperate! Moreover, by fearing you will be winkled out one day, you must be often waken up by the nightmares. Wellaway!

  • johnsmith9876

    US must thank bbcredux and the Chinese government to justify all US policies regarding Chinese investment in the US. Since both countries have the same goal, of excluding each other in owning their businesses, this is a great opportunity for China and the US to exchange ideas about how to strengthen and enforce their foreign ownership policies to ensure that no Chinese business will be owned by US interests.

    I just wonder why there was such furor in China when US exercises the same policy, while Chinese hales the Chinese government’s move. This must be fairness with Chinese characteristics.

    Actually, I think the real reason for China to block this purchase was because supply of fruit juice in the Chinese market is a strategically important to the Chinese military, especial its space program. The fruit juice maker actually supplies the Chinese space program with rocket fuel. It is the fuel supply to the space program the Chinese government is protecting, not the fruit juice. The fruit juice container producer is the manufacturer of the protective shields of the Chinese space modules and rockets. Protecting the fruit juice industry is protecting the Chinese space program. Without the fruit juice and can producer, there will be no Chinese space program. Furthermore, all the naval ship construction will be in jeopardy too, as there won’t be any qualified steel plate for the Chinese navy.

  • johnsmith9876

    conscienceinchina: You are wrong. The CCP will never go away as long as there are enough submissive Han’s ready to die in the hands of Hans, and don’t have the guts to fight for their liberty, and the intelligence to tell truth from lies. The Hans, except those smart enough to escape, are just too afraid of the CCP/PLA and not smart enough to know what is good for them, and don’t have enough sense of responsibility for the off springs to fight for a future of their future generations.

  • conscienceinchina

    To the “Canadian”(LOL!) five-jiao “sing666″:

    Thank you for flattering me with “Falon Gong”(according to you). It’s my honour to have chance to be praised as a member of them. They have been fighting the dictator and the evil with peaceful ways for many years, and a large number of them have been detained, tortured, persecuted and butchered by your masters. Nevertheless, they are still persisting in doing that. I am verily unable to have enough condition and volition to become one of them, so, don’t apple-polish me once again, please!

    Comparing the five-jiaos who are the lowest-ranking animals just as you, they are saints!

    The irony is: Canada is a democratic country, you are a “Canadian”, you elect your leaders and your congress, yet they approved the “Falon Gong” as a legal organization…alackaday…!!! You must want to bash your leaders, but you must bash your head first, don’t you?

  • johnsmith9876

    Another good news from China.

    China has developed a way to control blood flow at extremities at high G manipulation on fighter aircraft with simple cotton gloves!

    http://upfile.cat898.com/UploadFile/2009-3/200931917821434.jpg
    http://img1.qq.com/news/pics/12774/12774445.jpg
    http://www.dfzs.js.cn/news/sszh/junshi/wjdt/200807/news_137685.html

    And the last was a J11 fighter !!!

    Since J11 and J10 is superior to F16, which requires special G suits, gloves and boots to control blood flow in pilots so that they don’t black out in high G maneuvers. China must have found a way to accomplish those with simple cotton gloves, a great scientific breakthrough in China.

  • johnsmith9876

    conscienceinchina: You are wrong again !!!! You said to sing666: “You must want to bash your leaders, but you must bash your head first, don’t you?”

    First of all, how do you know sing666′s head is important to her at all. She bashed her head in the Hong Kong airport repeatedly. That showed it wasn’t an important part of her body. It is just a bony casing for a gaseous sac. It won’t hurt her a bit bashing it, and demonstrated clearly she would do that readily. And reading what she wrote, she had demonstrated that it indeed contains only a gaseous sac. More importantly, she is a Chinese, and therefore the state of mind is typical.

    By the way, Canada is a great country. Any country with Dalai Lama as a citizen is a great country. And Canada wasn’t afraid of China to have Falon Gong as a legal association. Did you ever see all the Falon Gong protesting banners in front of all Chinese consulates in Canada ? It’s fun to watch Chinese consulate staff walking by those banners.

    No, sing666 is not Canadian. She is just an old fat Chinese woman screaming in airports, bashing her head. I don’t think the way she writes here is a result of the bashing, as these bashing isn’t hurting a thing.

  • conscienceinchina

    “Gaseous sac”! LOL! I couldn’t do anything except laughing! John, you are really awesome!

    Yeah, Canada is a magical country. It is verily unable to produce a “gaseous sac”. Pretending a “Canadian” while acting with typicle five-jiao behaviors is truly unadvisable.

  • conscienceinchina

    To the “democracy-activist” five-jiao “laohong”:

    You “was fighting for democracy some 30 years ago in China” allegedly. That’s not impossible. The problem is, when did you surrender to the “State Security Bureau”? How many your former fellows were betrayed by you? Here I would like to send you a Chinese idiom “selecting the never boiled one among a large pile of kettles with boiled water (哪壶不开提哪壶)”. You may pretend any role but the “democracy activist”!

    Greeting another one’s mother is you Wumaos’ habit, just as your comrade “sing666” commited on Johnsmith.

    Your presence here is just for flaunting your age? Time can add one’s age and wrinkles, but can not always promote his (her) conscience, morality, breeding and wisdom.

    “‘Warriors or dissidents’ are only a small bunch of human gabbages”(“laohong” says). —Yeah, I do agree with you. So, we Chinese are much cherishing them due to their rarity, instead of hating, vilifying and attacking them just as you doing. They are the only hope for the future of the miserable Chinese. Without them, without tomorrow!

    “what you consider as ‘ideal’ is nothing new to millions of Chinese intellectuals”(“laohong” says). —Right! Chinese people have been seeking it for a long long time, whereas your masters tell us “democracy is poison” and then do everything they can do to snuff out the “liberalized thought”, “capitalist poisoned seedling ”.

    “They (Chinese people) prefer to sacrifice the ideal for the moment for a stronger China”(laohong says).—Ha-ha-ha-ha! That’s just your master CCP and you jackals dream, which is apparently showing you hoof! We “sacrifice the moment” so that you can maintain your “Chinese characteristic socialism” which can offers you doing everything you want.

    At the end, I want to send you a sentence: One thousand sentences of delicate lies can not win one simple truth!

    ————————————————————————————–
    laohong Says:

    To conscienceinchina son,
    –”warriors are still insisting on their ideal…Democracy will never be stopped by the tyranny”?

    You know what? When I was fighting for democracy some 30 years ago in China, your mother was still a virgin in the country village waiting to be lifted up from poverty-line by CCP. I just wonder how ridicular “democracy’ sounds from an low IQ and psycomplex like you, when the word become a cheap luxury. You are too dense to know what you called “warriors or dissidents” are only a small bunch of human gabbages consist of only 0.001% of Chinese population and what you consider as “ideal” is nothing new to millions of Chinese intellectuals. The difference is they prefer to sacrifice the ideal for the moment for a stronger China while your type including Gao Zhisheng are willing to sell your lubed azz to US neo-cons who never stop dreaming to keep CHina weak in their geopolitical agenda.
    As to your calling me and everybody here as a “50-cent”, I repeat it again–In a dog’s eyes, all human being you are barking at look the same.

  • conscienceinchina

    Correction: We “sacrifice the ideal” so that you can maintain your “Chinese characteristic socialism” which can offers you doing everything you want.

  • johnsmith9876

    “When I was fighting for democracy some 30 years ago in China, ”

    Sounds like CCP brain washed you after your mother gave birth to your first son. Hmm.. since you have no idea what democracy is, you must be fighting for democracy with Chinese characteristics.

blog comments powered by Disqus