Beijing and New Media: Is the Eye of Sauron Turning to Twitter?

There have been a wide range of comments in various media making comparisons between Tiananmen in 1989 and Teheran today, including one of our own posts, which wondered about the authorities reactions in China. Over at the China Media Project, David Bandurski highlighted a Guangming Daily article which blamed western media forces for stirring up trouble in Iran. Interestingly, as well as the usual suspects like CNN and the BBC, the article cited Twitter and noted that a U.S. State Department official had specifically called Twitter executives to ask them to delay scheduled maintenance that would hve interrupted service in Iran. A couple of days later, an article (here in Chinese; thanks as ever to the indefatigable Russ Moses for pointing it out) in the People’s Daily took up the Twitter point and argued that there was an unspoken collusion between new media and the U.S. government that constituted a new “e-diplomacy” by which Washington was pursuing it’s nefarious ends (in this case spreading its “value system,” a not very subtle code word for you-know-what). More so than the Guangming daily article, this piece dwells on the role of Twitter in Iran and  its apparent cooperation with the  U.S. State Department. Without reading too much into these two articles, it seems clear that along with worries about color revolutions, the authorities long have been perfectly aware of the dangers posed by mobile phones and text messaging but may just be beginning to realize that social networking tools like Twitter could pose a problem in difficult situations too. Coming in the wake of the sudden hysteria over Green Dam (see posts passim) and then the thwacking of Google (ditto), it does make one wonder whether Twitter’s China people are feeling a little nervous right now…..

Related Topics: China
  • Latest on Global Spin

    Yin Dongxun/Xinhua/ZUMAPRESS.com

    Jerusalem Day in the Old City: The Conflict Marches On

    Sunday was Jerusalem Day in Israel, a holiday once again observed by thousands of young Jews who chanted as they marched through Arab neighborhoods conquered in the 1967 Six Day War. The tension is always highest in the narrow passages of the largely Palestinian Old City. So much so that the city’s police this year tried to route the column of youths — most singing patriotic and religious songs, a few chanting “Death to the Arabs” — away from the Arab Quarter. But in the end, the police proved powerless against tradition, and the original route was restored. On Jerusalem Day, marching through the Arab Quarter is the whole point.

    Pablo Martinez Monsivais / AP

    Obama’s Afghanistan Problem: Neither Karzai Nor the Taliban Like the ‘Reconciliation’ Script

    President Barack Obama huddled with President Hamid Karzai in Chicago on Sunday, urging Afghanistan’s leader to accelerate negotiations with the Taliban over a political solution to the longest war in America’s history. But the prospect for Karzai negotiating successfully with the insurgents is clouded by a question raised by Josef Stalin, on the eve of World War II, in response to the suggestion that he offer concessions to the Pope: “How many divisions does he have?” The Taliban now ask the same question about Karzai. And should the Afghan leader also ask himself the question, he might reach a similarly dispiriting conclusion. Karzai’s independent power base is minimal, as is his ability to influence the outcome of his country’s civil war absent direct U.S. involvement. And that gives neither Karzai nor the Taliban much incentive to cut a deal with the other.

    JOSEPH EID/AFP/GettyImages

    Must-Reads from Around the World, May 21, 2012

    Spillover - Lebanon’s Daily Star reports on escalating violence inside the country after soldiers shot dead a prominent anti-Bashar al-Assad Muslim preacher Sunday. “The gravity of the incident… prompted leaders on both sides of the political divide to call for calm and restraint to prevent the country from sliding into sectarian strife as a result of a spillover of the 15-month-old uprising in neighboring Syria,” it says.

  • http://underthejacaranda.wordpress.com C.A. Yeung

    Simon:
    1. My understanding is that Twitter, Flictr, YouTube and Hotmail have all been on and off in many places in China since the start of June. But then I’m not in China. So if it’s not the case I stand to be corrected.
    2. DEBKAfile published a very good report a couple of days ago to warn organisers of political movements against relying too much on computer technology. In the case of Iran, this reliance has actually backfired badly at the most critical time, leaving organisers and opposition leaders totally exposed to government crackdowns.
    3. If the content of Twitter and SMS messages are still left largely uncensored in the PRC, you may want to ask why. The technology is definitely there. In any case, happy twittering.

  • johnsmith9876

    We all know that the internet is evil, especially for people who need to be under control. Twitter, Facebook, Flickr, Youtube, Hotmail, Google.cn etc. all make the internet even easier to use, and carry information in more ways to infiltrate and corrupt people who are easily corrupted, and hence need to be under control. Governments of these countries must stop the evil corrupting power of internet, or just any communication methods using electronic means. Cell phone is the other bad influence on people with easily manipulated minds which were protected from any western influence before, and now exposed to evil messages from the west. These feeble minds are just not ready to be exposed to ideas different from what their government deemed appropriate.

    The only solution to these people is to quit cold turkey, enforced by their government.

    We must realize that the most important thing for China and Iran is to put food one their table, especially river crab. Everyone must have river craba in every meal, and as snacks. And having a green dam in every home will ensure unlimited supply of river crabs, which require water behind the dam to multiply.

  • http://underthejacaranda.wordpress.com C.A. Yeung

    1 July 2009 is going to be a big day: 4Chans against River Crabs. Not to be missed.

    Here is a LINK for those linguistically challenged.

  • johnsmith9876

    What is this ? http://tinyurl.com/kqslb4
    “近来,一些企业提出工作量大、时间仓促、准备不足。根据实际情况,可以推迟预装。” What ? A delay on such an important necessity for all Chinese netizens ? The Chinese government abandoning their responsibility of protecting all the Chinese internet users from the evil information ? OK, it is just a delay. But exposing Chinese to more days of dangerous information is an affront to the Chinese people and hurting their easily bruise feeling.

    The Chinese netizens better back down from their request and not force the Chinese government to use even more extreme measures to enforce information control to protect you. Netizens must give up now before the PLA’s are called in to use phyiscal forces in additional to the cybar forces to help you realize the real intention of the Chinese government.

  • http://underthejacaranda.wordpress.com C.A. Yeung

    John Smith: I’m afraid the River Crab Hunters are not 100% happy with this delay tactic. The war is on.

  • chinabriefing

    It must be foreign infiltration in the Chinese internet network. There is no better explanation for this failure of policy execution and the organization of resistance of netizens. Sing666 and 2morrow will have to answer for this – how did the CIA fail to get any intel on this? They still don’t behave exactly like fenqing should. Their disguise may be blown.
    As for Green Dam, the CCP obviously thinks Chinese need to be controlled. Or else it will lead to chaos. Chinese are intrinsically barbaric and homicidal; if they aren’t imprisoned they will go around killing people for the fun of it. Just like how Chengguan kill citizens for the fun of it. Netizens vs CCP: game on!

  • 2morrow2

    While Jacky Chan’s famous commentary on the need for control may lack of sophisication, the belief that no control is needed or there is no control in the so-called democratic nations is inevitably naive.
    The China bashing clan is so easy to get excited on every single incident due to their own lack of interest and opportunity in everyday life proves this desperate jobless group of refugees are so damn boring.

  • chinabriefing

    Now 2morrow, you have short memory. George W. Bush sent you to wiretap and spy on your own citizens remember? Obviously, Bush thinks Americans need to be controlled too. Don’t they teach logic reasoning and the strawman theory in CIA seminars? “Some” is a good word to add to your CIA vocab.

    CIA lesson of the day: google “checks and balances”, James Madison; “separation of powers”, Montesquieu; western parliamentary democracy, Zhao Ziyang. It will assist you on your next CIA mission by helping you understand the difference between rule of man vs the rule of law. Chinese needs to be controlled by the former; Americans are controlled by the latter.

blog comments powered by Disqus