Cold Case: How Libya’s Revolution Might Solve a 1984 Murder

One April evening in 1984, an after-work drink took a surreal turn. On the way to a bar, we skirted a police cordon at the entrance to St James’s Square in central London; we had barely lifted our pints before armed officers clattered into our midst and informed us that the cordon had been extended. We were not to leave. The Libyan embassy was under siege and a figure had been seen at the back of the building, heading in our general direction.

Earlier that day, a diminutive policewoman called Yvonne Fletcher had been shot dead and 11 demonstrators injured by gunfire outside the embassy, or “Libyan People’s Bureau” as its incumbents called it. A supporter of Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi, apparently incensed by a peaceful vigil protesting the regime’s execution of two students in Tripoli, had opened fire from an upstairs window. Police and special forces quickly surrounded the building, and despite the reports of a fleeing figure, almost certainly prevented the gunman and any accomplices from leaving. Yet on the basis—later disputed—that the men inside the embassy enjoyed diplomatic immunity, the British authorities gave no order to storm the building. The siege lasted 10 days (we were released from the neighboring bar rather sooner, after only a few hours) and ended when the Libyans were allowed to depart for their home country, taking the murder weapon and other evidence with them.

The police believed they knew who pulled the trigger—listening devices picked up an agitated discussion inside the building that seemed to implicate a man called Omar Ahmed Sodani—but U.K. detectives were never given access to him, even after Libya handed over the Lockerbie suspects for trial in 1999. Queenie Fletcher waited in vain for justice for her slain daughter and told the BBC she felt “let down” after the 2009 release of convicted Lockerbie bomber Abdelbaset Ali Al-Megrahi.

It has taken a violent eruption of the same dissident spirit that brought the protestors to the Libyan embassy that day in 1984 to revive hopes of justice that had faded like memories. Yesterday rebel forces in Libya invited foreign media to meet a Gaddafi loyalist they had captured. It was Sodani, in latter years the head of Gaddafi’s militia in Benghazi and according to Kim Sengupta of The Independent captured 10 days ago hiding in a shed. Sodani denies the murder, claiming he was under arrest by British police at the time of Fletcher’s shooting. Despite the passage of years, such claims should be possible to test. Whether Sodani will be called to account under British law is far from certain. Sengupta reports that as Sodani was led away by his captors, he sounded fearful but professed “full confidence in the fairness of the revolution and the revolution’s judges.”

Subscribe to Catherine Mayer on Facebook
Related Topics: Muammar Gaddafi, Omar Ahmed Sodani, Yvonne Fletcher, Africa, arab uprisings, Dictatorships, Libya, Terrorism, U.K., Uncategorized
  • Latest on Global Spin

    Oded Balilty / Reuters

    Netanyahu’s New Government: Warming to Peace Talks with the Palestinians?

    A flurry of gestures toward the Palestinian leadership suggests that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, in his new role as leader of a center-right government, is warming toward the resumption of peace talks — or at least giving the appearance of warming; call it a rosy glow rising from a pair of announcements on Monday. One was about Palestinian prisoners who had been carrying out a mass hunger strike for weeks inside Israeli prisons. With several prisoners near death, Netanyahu approved an agreement that improves prison conditions and permits visits by family members in the Gaza Strip, the heavily guarded enclave that Palestinians have been allowed out of only for medical emergencies. Greeted by Palestinians as a victory, the deal eased concerns that a prisoner’s death might combust what are usually routine protests planned for Tuesday’s commemoration of Nakba Day, the “catastrophe” of Israel’s 1948 victory over Arab forces trying to prevent the establishment of a Jewish state.

    Bernat Armangue / AP

    Palestinians Mark Their Day of “Catastrophe”

    Protesters challenge Israeli troops in the West Bank while commemorating the Nakba, or “day of catastrophe” in Arabic, which marks the day when Israel declared its statehood in 1948—an act which forced thousands of Palestinians out of their homes and into a life of exile

    Christopher Furlong/ Getty Images

    Rebekah Brooks, Husband Charged in Phone-Hacking Scandal

    The convoluted saga of the British phone-hacking scandal seems to have been dragging on longer than a back-to-back performance of Wagner’s Ring Cycle. Yet despite the demise of Rupert Murdoch‘s News of the World, the launching of a public inquiry into British press standards, three police investigations and more than 40 arrests, the scandal has yet to draw real blood. The closest it has come was a report released this month by a Parliamentary committee, which accused Murdoch of turning a blind eye to the hacking at his paper and declared him “not a fit person” to run an international company — a damning conclusion that nonetheless seems to have had little immediate effect.

  • deconstructiva

    Catherine, more great reporting, thanks. If only the police had forced you and friends to stay in the bar for ten days. I’d presume you’d get free drinks and snacks. US bars’ most popular foods include chicken wings, “sliders” mini-burgers, nachos, and loaded fries. What are fave bar foods there?
    .
    As for cold case, seriously, it’s good to see suspect caught. I hope police can finish investigation and trials. However, since Gaddafi still rules for now, I’d guess extradition is out. But would things change quickly (or at all) when he’s gone and rebels take over? Or do not-so-legal means exist for rebels to turn him over? If he “somehow” winds up at the British Embassy or a consulate and thus on YOUR turf instead of Gaddafi’s, does that change the diplomatic game at all or not? Or can I imply from last paragraph that the rebels may conduct justice on their own and to hell with Gaddafi? (Many questions, yes, sorry, but I really don’t know.) Thanks for your thoughts.

  • deconstructiva

    …and way off topic, but in case no one else at TIME brings this up soon: just read news about Canada’s no-confidence vote. Playing what-if worst-case scenario, what happens in Canada, UK, and other parliamentary countries if a Prime Minister loses a no-confidence vote, ignores conventional rules, and simply refuses to leave? Do the Canadians have to arrest him? In the UK, can the Queen kick out a squatting PM? There’s no relation to Libya or Ivory Coast situations other than pondering what happens when leaders refuse to go or otherwise don’t play by the rules, but am curious. Enjoy your weekend, Catherine.

blog comments powered by Disqus