Iraq’s Assault on Camp Ashraf: The Tenuous Life of a Fringe Iranian Faction

Update: The U.N. reported on April 14 that 34 people were killed during the raid on Camp Ashraf last week.

Was ever there a stranger lot than the Mujahedin-e-Khalk Organization?  Today its military arm stands braced for the worst in Camp Ashraf, a dusty military base tucked into a corner of a once-welcoming host nation, Iraq, that last week sent troops in, killing either three, or 33, depending on the account. But 30 years ago the MKO, also known as the MEK, also known as the People’s Mujahedin, was in the thick of the 1979 Iranian revolution, the heavyweight contender from the Communist end of the spectrum, slugging it out for control of the rebellion against the Islamists gathered behind Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini.  The ayatollah’s side prevailed, rounding up MKOs by the thousands and hanging them day after day after day in Evin Prison. I know a man whose job, as a prisoner, was dragging away the bodies; he still has nightmares. The MKO got its licks in too; Khomeini’s successor sports a prosthetic hand since losing his own when an MKO bomb went off in a 1981 meeting.

That’s pretty much where things have stood since. Except that as the Islamists have grown harder, the MKO has grown weirder.  Inside Iran, they remain a significant, albeit underground — even ghostly — opposition presence, skilled at survival but with eyes pealed for chances to wound the regime.  In recent years, that’s mostly been by exposing its nuclear secrets. It was the MKO that, going by the name National Council of Resistance of Iran, revealed the nuclear facilities at Natanz and Arak.

Outside Iran, the group came to look more and more like a cult – with tanks. Its headquarters ended up in suburban Paris, where leaders Massoud Rajavi and his wife Maryam exerted unusual control over members, dictating among other things who would sleep with whom.  (Women’s rights featured in the explanation.)  When French riot police stormed the compound in 2003, nine members protested by setting themselves on fire.

Thousands of others MKO loyalists remained as physically close to Iran as possible, on low, brown hills on the Iraq side of the border. During the eight-year Iran-Iraq war, they had fought for Saddam Hussein, earning a vicious reputation for mercenary attacks on the Iraqi Kurdish population that, in a parallel betrayal, had chosen to side with Iran.

Then the Americans invaded. In the first days of the war, U.S. Special Forces directed a few bombing strikes on MKO positions in early 2003 before the order came to take the Iranian exiles prisoner while the Bush Administration debated what to do with them.  There was serious talk of turning them loose against the mullahs, but in the end the 3,500 loyalists remained in Camp Ashraf,  located in Diyala Province within striking distance both of the Iraqi Kurds and Iran. In 2009, as U.S. forces prepared to pull out, they became Iraq’s problem again, except Saddam was no longer around. Their host country was now run by some of the people the MKO hunted on his behalf — a government of Kurds and Shiites that, in addition to the memory of facing MKO tanks, values its close relations with the Islamic Republic of  Iran.

Which brings us to the events of last week. Iraqi forces entered Camp Ashraf after fighting broke out, apparently over efforts to return some of the land under the camp to local farmers.  They wanted to plant barley on it again. Iraqi commanders said only three MKO were killed, caught under the wheels of military vehicles. Camp residents put the number at 33, and said they were fired upon.  When reporters were bused to the site, the Iranian exiles held up a banner reading: “Stop right here and let us tell the crimes.”  The bus drove on.

Related Topics: Borders, Conflict, iran, Middle East, Terrorism, U.S., Uncategorized
  • Latest on Global Spin

    Oded Balilty / Reuters

    Netanyahu’s New Government: Warming to Peace Talks with the Palestinians?

    A flurry of gestures toward the Palestinian leadership suggests that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, in his new role as leader of a center-right government, is warming toward the resumption of peace talks — or at least giving the appearance of warming; call it a rosy glow rising from a pair of announcements on Monday. One was about Palestinian prisoners who had been carrying out a mass hunger strike for weeks inside Israeli prisons. With several prisoners near death, Netanyahu approved an agreement that improves prison conditions and permits visits by family members in the Gaza Strip, the heavily guarded enclave that Palestinians have been allowed out of only for medical emergencies. Greeted by Palestinians as a victory, the deal eased concerns that a prisoner’s death might combust what are usually routine protests planned for Tuesday’s commemoration of Nakba Day, the “catastrophe” of Israel’s 1948 victory over Arab forces trying to prevent the establishment of a Jewish state.

    Bernat Armangue / AP

    Palestinians Mark Their Day of “Catastrophe”

    Protesters challenge Israeli troops in the West Bank while commemorating the Nakba, or “day of catastrophe” in Arabic, which marks the day when Israel declared its statehood in 1948—an act which forced thousands of Palestinians out of their homes and into a life of exile

    Christopher Furlong/ Getty Images

    Rebekah Brooks, Husband Charged in Phone-Hacking Scandal

    The convoluted saga of the British phone-hacking scandal seems to have been dragging on longer than a back-to-back performance of Wagner’s Ring Cycle. Yet despite the demise of Rupert Murdoch‘s News of the World, the launching of a public inquiry into British press standards, three police investigations and more than 40 arrests, the scandal has yet to draw real blood. The closest it has come was a report released this month by a Parliamentary committee, which accused Murdoch of turning a blind eye to the hacking at his paper and declared him “not a fit person” to run an international company — a damning conclusion that nonetheless seems to have had little immediate effect.

  • http://moises1234.wordpress.com moises1234

    This article is offensive and deeply disturbing at a time when people are mourning the loss of friends and family at Camp Ashraf.

    I have 8 family members living at Camp Ashraf and to read this despicable article is utterly disgusting.

    Unfortunately the tone and timing of the piece shows the writer’s allegiances. Why does this writer fail to mention statements issued by Amnesty International, Reporters Without Borders, the British Bar Human Rights Committee etc which clearly define the massacre that took place at Camp Ashraf.

    Rather Karl Vick has decided to concentrate his efforts on regurgitating Iranian regime propaganda. The same allegations put forward by the British and EU when they attempted to justify the continued ban on the PMOI. Courts in the EU and UK found in favour of the PMOI at each and every occasion.

    This piece does not even justify being called journalism, it is a shameful piece of propaganda which attempts to justify the massacre of unarmed civilians.

  • http://mohammad84.wordpress.com mohammad84

    What an absolute load of rubbish. The author is clearly saying the same untruths that the Iranian regime is saying about this incident. And he is repeating the mullahs’ misinformation about the Mojahedin.

  • http://sheila120.wordpress.com sheila120

    Uh, I forgot, what a load of rubbish! Completely untrue, as if it is a member of Mullahs regime writting it!

  • rezvan1

    Is the writer of this article implying that current policy makers, former policy makers and majority of US Congress who support the MEK as the main opposition are misguided? I’m not sure of where the writer of this article gets his facts (Iranian Regime?) from but clearly it’s all propaganda from Iranian Intelligence. There was a gathering of more than 100,000 people in Paris last June in support of MEK. The writer is trying to justify criminal actions of the Iraqi government and barbaric regime of Iran by violating the rights of Iranian people and their main resistant forces! We have seen the same type of writing from this writer when the main opposition was under attack. In the past 30 years more than 120,000 members and supporters of MEK we’re executed by Iranian regime. This doesn’t even include the thousands who are in prison; this for sure doesn’t look like a “fringe” or “cult” organization. Study the history of close to half a century of MEK and their struggle of men and woman who have given more for liberation of their people than any other force. There is not enough time for me to tear your false statements apart. You’re either extremely naïve, uninformed or possibly being paid handsomely by the Iranian regime or their lobbyist to spread false information.

  • http://sandshir.wordpress.com sandshir

    This article is nothing but another chewed up and recycled version of the propaganda that the Iranian regime has fed the world since its conception regarding the MEK. The State Department in its case with the Federal District Court relied on this same time of misinformation that the article uses and the court rejected it because even the state department couldn’t vouch for its authenticity. When the US went into Iraq following 9/11, the state department was getting its information on the MEK from Iranian regime sources, heavily rooted in lobbying the US government at a time when terrorism was #1 on the political agenda as the debt crisis’s is today. A 4 year old child knows that you can not rely on information given by the same person who wants your destruction, it is misinformation and a campaign conducted by Tehran to clout the only opposition group that is a threat to its survival, and unfortunately some here in the US by it.

  • brutus9448

    They went to war against their own country and country men. They killed soldiers that had nothing to do with mullah and were fighting sadam to defend their country. They desrve what they get

  • http://invincible20.wordpress.com invincible20

    First of all let me tell people like Karl Vick how they get money or gift from Iranian governments like Hitlers regime gifted the authors who discredited the allies during World War II, this article reminds me of people like NIAC and trita parsi who are getting money from Iranian government and are under investigation by FBI now.Writing Articles like this is selling yourself to the devil, my friends people like Karl Vick are the ones who support Ahmadinejad and Khamenei with the Mask covering their face, this article is all lies, supporting murderers of unarmed people is shameful, these articles help Ahmadinejads government to kill more innocent people and straighten the Mullahs for future, AS THE WHOLE WORLD WATCHED WHEN NEDA WAS MURDERED, now Iraqi government is killing NEDA’S FRIENDS!!! GOD BLESS FREEDOM LOVERS !!! LONG LIVE IRANIAN FREEDOM FIGHTERS MOJAHEDIN, ALL PEOPLE OF IRAN!!!

  • http://azadii111.wordpress.com azadii111

    What a load of tripe!!

    This is total nonsense and rubbish! They wanted to plant barley and return land to farmers?????????? Are you kidding me??

    The writer claims that ‘Iraq, that last week sent troops in, killing either three, or 33, depending on the account.’ – Depending on the account? What about the account of the UN that says it has seen 28 bodies at Camp Ashraf. It says that 25 bodies had gunshot wounds and at least three appeared to have been crushed by vehicles. A further 6 have died in hospitals in Barquba and Baghdad.

    Who is this reporter? What is his reasons for publishing such baseless nonsense?

    Time has lost its credibility as far as I am concerned.

  • http://azadii111.wordpress.com azadii111

    Oh scum like you peer your head out of the rocks you live under and show your true colors.

    Attacking unarmed people, shooting at them, driving over them with military vehicles. You get off on it? At least we can see you for what you really are!

    You are probably the same person who enjoys hearing about women get raped in prisons in Iran. You enjoy seeing people being tortured and beaten.

    I wonder how you sleep at night?!??

  • http://pooya2011.wordpress.com pooya2011

    I’m surprised TIME actually allows publication of such a biased article. Mr. Vick has a long history of coming to the aid of Iranian mullahs and has shown once again that he is still commiteed to them.

  • http://azadii111.wordpress.com azadii111

    This is indeed offensive and disturbing. Although it is not surprising that Mr Vick is one of only a handful of people who have come to the aid of the Iranian regime at such a time, spreading lies and misinformation! The regime will face its inevitable downfall very soon, I wonder what Mr Vick will have to say then!!

  • http://biggreenduck.wordpress.com biggreenduck

    I don’t know who Karl Vick is, or why he is referred to as a journalist. But when I looked at the videos shot by these Iranian dissidents I see guns being fired into crowds and an unarmed man being killed as he is run over by a hummer. I then see video of 30+ men and women laying dead with sheets on them. I know you can deny the truth as person, but how can a “journalist” who isn’t present for the shootings/driving over of human beings report as if he was present?

    Time Magazine needs to explain why Vick “reports” things that Reporters who where actually there don’t even say. The reporters in Iraq who went to camp ashraf said the Iraqi’s would not let reporters into the camp. How can Mr. Vic know things that he was not present to comment on?

    If you buy Time Magazine, it is worth a call to say…it is high time for Time Inc. to dump Mr. Karl Vick unless of course you want to pay for a mouthpiece for the PR machine of the Iranian mullah terrorists with your subscription price!

  • http://propeace11.wordpress.com propeace11

    It is because of people like Karl Vick that the world can never be peaceful. It is ignoring people like this guy who can watch videos of how unarmed people are being run over and shot at, and then write about how they deserve it.

    Absolutely thick and heartless person. I really dont know how Time would allow such garbage on their website. I can no longer consider this as a credible source of getting news.

    Its amazing how people can still support the terrorist regime of Iran. After all the murders and terrors that they have and are still continuing to carry out.

    Shame on you Karl

  • http://propeace11.wordpress.com propeace11

    shame on you. We should be working to stop this, not to condone it or even suggest its tolerable.

  • http://tghaemi.wordpress.com tghaemi

    History repeat itself. There were un-educated writers like you who wrote and supported the removal of Dr. Mossadegh in 1953 and 60 years later the US government appologized for removing the democratically elected prime minster. You should be ashame of yourself for writing junks like this. Time magazine, you should think twice to allow your reputation gets damaged by someone who supports a mafia system regime in Iran which in 21st century stone people to death. Wake up.

  • http://mansoori8.wordpress.com mansoori8

    What a piece of junk this ugly face has written.
    I just couldn’t believe my eyes to see such an article trampling all the principles of journalism by resorting to such fabricated facts which originates from the mullahs regime.
    It is a saying that every creature, including this so-called Mr. Vick, has a price.
    By judging and looking at this piece of junk, one can only tends to appreciate the extend of his animosity against the PMOI which goes back to 1980′s.
    By taking such a position and stance vis-a vis the religious dictatorship ruling Iran, it is tantamount to complicity with the crimes perpetrated by the mullahs in the past three decades not only in Iran but across the globe.
    Shame on you Vick. You deserve nothing but the curse of those who have lost their beloved ones at the hands of the criminals like Al-Maliki and his mercenaries.

  • http://freeomfighter.wordpress.com freeomfighter

    FreedomFighter:

    J’accuse

    Karl Vick,

    I hereby accuse you and your establishment of misleading, biased, insidious, fact-fiction mixing journalism, and providing a platform for the war criminals who committed acts of Crime against Humanity on the infamous day of April 8th 2011 and thereafter, mowing down and massacreing unarmed, innocent and Protected Persons at Camp Ashraf, North of Baghdad.

    Your name will be recorded in the annals of journalism as an individual with no heart, humanity integrity or qualifications as being in this honorable profession journalism. You have provided a platform for the two most soul-destroying tyrannies which have darkened the stained pages of history; that of the Savages of Tehran and their mercenaries, the barbaric regime of Iraq, under Nouri Al-Maliki, a bloodthirsty stooge of Ali Khamenei, the so-called supreme leader of the mullahcracy in Tehran.

    All at the cost of more than 34 fallen, more than 6 of them brave women, and several hundred wounded, destruction and looting of many millions of dollars worth of property belonging to the 3400 Protected Persons at the hallowed grounds of Camp Ashraf.

    It is not too late to take a stab at exonerating yourself and your discredited outfit. Just retract the garbage you have spouted and report the facts, and that is the War Crimes and Crime against Humanity, committed by the direct order of Al-Maliki through TEXT-MESSAGING, under the direction of mullahs in Tehran and the active participation of the terrorist Qods Force and the Iranian embassy in Baghdad.

    FreedomFighter

  • http://freeomfighter.wordpress.com freeomfighter

    FreedomFighter

    What a shame for a so-called journalist to concoct such absolute nonsense emanating from his lack of respect for human rights and her resorting to the worst form of YELLOW JOURNLAISM. Did this man verify that more than 6 lionesses of the Camp Ashraf were the target of savagery by the Iraqi forces in collusion with the Qods Force of the mullahs? There have been reports that they spoke Farsi as they were mowing the innocent residents!!!

    Have you no shame; though your inhumanity has been laid bare by quoting the savages speaking for the Iraqi government, under the influence of the Iranian mullahs. How can you live with yourself, when more than 34 people have been verified to have been massacred in a case of Crime against Humanity, and WAR CRIMES, by all relevant Human Rights Organizations and the United Nations?

    I guess the only reason one can come up with is that you have some sort big stake in fabricating these unbelievable lies…

    FreedomFighter

  • http://freeomfighter.wordpress.com freeomfighter

    FreedomFighter

    I am absolutely shocked, not only at the incredibly insensitive reporter of this article, but at the outfit that has this character under its employment to allow such unbelievable Nazi type propaganda to be disseminated.

    The State Department, of all places, has condemned this act of barbarism. Secretary Gates (he was meeting with Al-Maliki at the time of the atrocities) has made statements against it. Not that his statement exonerates him of not stopping the attack.

    Amnesty International has strongly condemned the savagery… Senator Carl Levin and Senator John Kerry have both condemned it. How can an organization that considers itself reputable, allow a questionable creature such as Karl Vick to post such bold face lies.

    We demand an immediate apology, a retraction, and equal space to respond to this woman’s allegations and her affiliations, without delay.

    FreedomFighter

blog comments powered by Disqus