Talking Past Each Other: Hamas Broaches Peace While Israel Sees Only Terror

Almost unnoticed on Wednesday, as two rival Palestinian factions agreed to bury the hatchet, was the head of Hamas announcing that his group, which exists for armed struggle against Israel, was willing to give peace with the Jewish state a chance, too.  The statement from Khaled Mashal was grudging and hardly optimistic, but cut enough against the grain of expectations to qualify as news.

“We have given peace since Madrid till now 20 years, and I say we are ready to agree among us Palestinians and with Arab support to give an additional chance,” Mashal told the audience in Cairo, where Hamas had pitched up to sign a unity agreement with Fatah.

What made news instead was Israel’s pre-emptive rejection of anything of the sort.  ”What happened today is a deadly blow to the peace process and a major prize for terror,” said prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, speaking in London at the start of a European swing intended to dissuade Western governments from supporting a UN vote on a Palestinian state later this year.  It’s an uphill fight, but Netanyahu sees danger in the reconciliation of the Fatah party — which is secular, moderate and works closely with Israeli operatives to suppress violence on the West Bank — with Hamas, whose charter calls for the destruction of Israel, and a few weeks ago was launching rockets into Israeli cities from the Gaza Strip, where it governs.

The challenge, for the Israelis, is the hard-earned image of moderation nurtured in recent years by the West Bank leaders, notably Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and his prime minister, Salam Fayyad.  Their efforts at state-building and suppressing terror have won a great deal of good will from the West, so much so that Hillary Clinton told reporters on Thursday that the U.S. was taking a wait and see attitude on unity. Indeed what most immediately pre-occupied American diplomats this week was Israel’s continued holding of $89 million in tax receipts owed to Fayyad’s government, and held back as punishment for making up with Hamas. (The move was not supported unanimously within the Israeli government, according to the daily Ha’aretz, which quotes a senior defense official as saying, “Fayyad chased Hamas money more effectively than we did. He shouldn’t be apologizing…”)

Hamas is, of course, Hamas, but after four years as the sole governing power in Gaza that is, more than ever, a political beast. In Cairo, Mashad touched all the bases, making common cause with Fatah and other peacemakers by calling for a Palestinian state on 1967 boundaries. In another breath, he endorsed “resistance in all its forms.”  But the tone seemed clear enough, at least coming from a group whose name is an acronym in Arabic for “Islamic Resistance Movement.”

“We are not declaring war on anyone,” Mashad said, but added, after vowing to give peace a chance, that he didn’t expect much, “because Israel does not respect us, and because Israel has rejected all our initiatives and because Israel deliberately rejects Palestinian rights, rejects Fatah members as well as Hamas.”

Related Topics: Benjamin Netanyahu, cairo, Fatah, Hamas, Hillary Clinton, Israel, Khaled Mashal, Mahmoud Abbas, Palestinian Authority, Salam Fayyad, Egypt, Islam, israel, Middle East, Palestinian, Terrorism, U.K., U.S., Uncategorized
  • Latest on Global Spin

    Oded Balilty / Reuters

    Netanyahu’s New Government: Warming to Peace Talks with the Palestinians?

    A flurry of gestures toward the Palestinian leadership suggests that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, in his new role as leader of a center-right government, is warming toward the resumption of peace talks — or at least giving the appearance of warming; call it a rosy glow rising from a pair of announcements on Monday. One was about Palestinian prisoners who had been carrying out a mass hunger strike for weeks inside Israeli prisons. With several prisoners near death, Netanyahu approved an agreement that improves prison conditions and permits visits by family members in the Gaza Strip, the heavily guarded enclave that Palestinians have been allowed out of only for medical emergencies. Greeted by Palestinians as a victory, the deal eased concerns that a prisoner’s death might combust what are usually routine protests planned for Tuesday’s commemoration of Nakba Day, the “catastrophe” of Israel’s 1948 victory over Arab forces trying to prevent the establishment of a Jewish state.

    Bernat Armangue / AP

    Palestinians Mark Their Day of “Catastrophe”

    Protesters challenge Israeli troops in the West Bank while commemorating the Nakba, or “day of catastrophe” in Arabic, which marks the day when Israel declared its statehood in 1948—an act which forced thousands of Palestinians out of their homes and into a life of exile

    Christopher Furlong/ Getty Images

    Rebekah Brooks, Husband Charged in Phone-Hacking Scandal

    The convoluted saga of the British phone-hacking scandal seems to have been dragging on longer than a back-to-back performance of Wagner’s Ring Cycle. Yet despite the demise of Rupert Murdoch‘s News of the World, the launching of a public inquiry into British press standards, three police investigations and more than 40 arrests, the scandal has yet to draw real blood. The closest it has come was a report released this month by a Parliamentary committee, which accused Murdoch of turning a blind eye to the hacking at his paper and declared him “not a fit person” to run an international company — a damning conclusion that nonetheless seems to have had little immediate effect.

  • drorbenami

    Is this really supposed to be a balanced article? hamas throws people off the roofs of buildings, but we are really suppose to believe that they are willing to give peace a chance ?

    Who is this Karl Vick? Scott McCloud was biased, but this article by karl vick is sick. Let’s just ignore everything that has happened for the last 20 years shall we and just focus on what hamas said yesterday. good reporting karl…..

  • drorbenami

    Oh yes karl, I forgot……

    During the fighting in Gaza two years ago Time Magazine did a big story dealing with an Israeli soldier who wrote some graffiti on the wall about some woman’s underpants. Has Time’s crack team of reporters discovered the name of the soldier who committed this outrage against humanity ???

    Also, about 2 weeks ago an Italian peace activists who arrived in Gaza with the flotilla was murdered. Has Time Magazine printed a story identifiying the murderers?

    Finally, yesterday someone tried to killed Primi Minister Erdogan. Will Turkey be making an apology to the attackers ???

  • drorbenami

    Hi Karl,

    I kept asking myself: Who is this idiot Karl Rick? So, I checked and I see you are from “The State of 10,000 Lakes: Minnesota”.

    We in Israel are so stupid and so primative we hardly know anything about Minnesota. Could you please give us a little information about the 4 Chippewa and Ojibwe (Anishinaabe) reservations, as well as, the 4 Dakota (Sioux) reservations located in your state? Are the conditions there better or worse than in Gaza? They say that on reservations there is alot of unemployment, alcoholism and suicides? Is that true, Karl???

    I understand that Minnesota is the 12th largest state in the union, yet there are only 5 million “white settlers” living there today. In other words, you have a population less than Israel, yet a state with over 10 times as much land as Israel. Almost 87,000 sq. miles. Seems likes there is a lot of land for those Sioux and Chippewas, doesn’t it. Why are those people still on reservations, Karl???

    Also: Could you please give us a little information about “The Dakota War” of 1862 and the execution of 38 Native Americans ? Wikipedia says that was “the largest mass execution in United States history”. Is that correct, Karl? Were any members of the Vick family in the firing squad ?

    Please enlighten us: “Oh mighty defender of the Palestinian people”

  • michaelfury
  • http://3mmmzzz.wordpress.com 3mmmzzz

    Hello Karl,

    It is strange to read somthing like this these days especially in Times and from an American. I hope you will no be assasinated like Mabhouh or threatned like Richard Goldstone or fired like Rick Sanchez and so one and so for. I’m sure you will find many other examples which will let you think twice before even thinking this way next time.
    Oviously the style in the previous posts is well know: It doesn’t matter what are you saying the only think which matter when you are not pro israel is who you are and next step is every thing but rational talking.

    Thank you again foro your courage :)
    Kind Regards,

  • drorbenami

    you obviously don’t read too much…..karl vick is only the last in a long line of Time correspondants who have written articles against Israel….For example: Scott MacCloud was Times Cairo correspondant for years, yet he never wrote anything about Egypt, only Israel.

    But maybe you can explain it too us. Why is it okay for Karl Vick’s grandparents to come frome Europe and take Indian Land by force, but you feel it is so wrong for Israel to purchase Palestian Land ?

blog comments powered by Disqus